Face-to-Face vs. Technology-Driven Speaking Tests: A TOEFL Connection

In this episode of the TOEFL Speaking Prep Podcast, we dive deep into a fascinating study from King Saud University, comparing face-to-face speaking assessments with technology-driven lab tests. What’s the verdict? From the personalized touch of human interaction to the consistency and accessibility of AI tools like SpeechRater, we explore how both approaches impact TOEFL preparation.

Discover how AI is revolutionizing language learning by offering personalized feedback, pinpointing areas for improvement, and creating opportunities for students worldwide. But can it replace the human connection that instructors value so much?

Join us as we unpack the balance between technology and human interaction, the role of community in learning, and practical tips for leveraging AI while maintaining that vital human touch. Whether you’re prepping for the TOEFL or passionate about language learning, this episode offers insights that will inspire and inform.

🎧 Tune in now to explore the best of both worlds and uncover your path to speaking confidence!

Source

Free TOEFL Speaking practice:

• My Speaking Score

Free resources:

• TOEFL Speaking Course
• SpeechRater Blog
• SpeechRater Knowledge Base

Social:

• Follow us on Facebook
• Subscribe on YouTube

My Speaking Score serves 000s of users across the globe by helping them data-power their TOEFL Speaking prep.

Transcript

Hey everybody and welcome back. You know, we've been hearing from a lot of you TOEFL preppers out there and one of the biggest things on your mind is how to nail that speaking section.

(0:44 - 0:47)
Oh, absolutely. It's a tough one. That's what we're diving into today.

(0:47 - 0:52)
Yeah. Now get this, we're going all the way to Saudi Arabia for this one. Okay.

(0:52 - 1:49)
Researchers at King Saud University did this really fascinating study about speaking assessments. And what they found has some pretty big implications for how we think about prepping for tests like the TOEFL, especially with all the new AI tools out there these days. Yeah. 

You know, this KSU study, it really highlights this challenge that we always have in language learning and that's, you know, how do we measure speaking skills? How do we know how well someone can actually speak? Right. Like how do you test that in a way that's fair and accurate for everybody? Exactly. And they were looking at two of the most common ways to do it. 

The first one being face-to-face testing, where you've got, you know, that one-on-one interaction with an instructor. Like a classic oral exam. Exactly. 

And then the second way is lab-based testing, which uses recordings. So it's kind of like a more standardized approach. It's interesting though, because that lab setup using recordings, it almost feels like an early version of what AI is doing today.

(1:49 - 1:58)
Oh, for sure. I mean, think about it. Even back then they were using MP3 players and recordings to give everyone the same questions, the same amount of time, to answer everything standardized.

(1:58 - 2:02)
Like a prototype. Yeah, exactly. And here's where things get really interesting.

(2:03 - 2:24)
The students and the instructors had totally different opinions about which method was better. Oh, really? Okay. So who liked what? Well, the students, they absolutely loved the Laptest. 

They said it made them less anxious. They got to practice with more diverse material and they felt like they were improving faster. Huh. 

Less anxiety, more material. Faster improvement. Sounds like a win-win.

(2:25 - 2:37)
You'd think so, right? So what was the problem? Why did the instructors feel the same way? Well, here's the twist. The majority of the instructors actually preferred the face-to-face approach, even though it took way more time. And get this, even though it wasn't as reliable for grading.

(2:38 - 3:13)
Wow. Less reliable, but they still preferred it. I'm starting to see why this research is so important. 

Like, it's not just about what feels right for the teacher. It's about what actually helps the students learn and perform their best, especially when it comes to something as high stakes as the TOEFL. Right. 

And when you dig into the reasons behind the instructor's preference, it actually makes a lot of sense. They said they liked that direct interaction with students, being able to see their faces, their reactions, having that unscripted conversation. I can see that. 

Like being in the room with the student and having that connection. Exactly. And they also said it was easier to grade on the spot.

(3:13 - 3:19)
You know, no need to listen back to recordings or anything. Sure. But they also admitted that it wasn't as reliable.

(3:19 - 3:58)
Yeah. There's definitely a trade off there. And this is where I think the research is so valuable. 

It's forcing us to look at the data and not just rely on gut feelings. So even with the best intentions, sometimes that human element can introduce bias. Exactly. 

And I think that's one of the things that AI is trying to address. To create a system that's both accurate and engaging. Right. 

And the study actually found that the lab-based tests, even though they might have felt less personal, they were statistically more reliable, more valid, and they had better discrimination power. Which means they were better at figuring out the actual skill level of each student. Which is crucial for the TOEFL, right? Yeah.

(3:58 - 4:33)
I mean, the whole point is to accurately reflect your English skills so that universities know you're ready for their programs. Exactly. And I think this is where we start to see the connection to AI and the future of language learning. 

Because those lab-based tests, they were kind of a precursor to what AI is doing now, but on a much larger scale. So AI is like taking those benefits of standardized testing and amplifying them. Exactly. 

AI can ensure that everyone gets the same questions the same amount of time to answer. And the grading is consistent no matter who's taking the test or who's grading it. Plus you can get feedback in a way that just wasn't possible before.

(4:34 - 5:06)
Right. AI can analyze your speaking pinpoint areas where you need to improve and even give you personalized suggestions. And remember those students in the study who loved the lab format because it made them less anxious? Well, AI can take that to a whole new level. 

It's like creating that perfect learning environment where you can focus on your skills without distractions or judgment. Precisely. And with tools like SpeechRater, you can get that detailed feedback on your pronunciation, your fluency, your grammar, all the things that matter for speaking confidently and effectively.

(5:06 - 5:18)
SpeechRater is a great example of how AI is changing the game for test prep, especially for TOEFL speaking. It's like having a personal speech coach available 24-7. It's pretty amazing when you think about it, like all the possibilities that AI is opening up.

(5:18 - 5:36)
Absolutely. Especially for students all over the world who might not have access to quality language instruction, you know, depending on where they live or their background. Right. 

With AI-powered tools, suddenly everyone has access to these incredible resources no matter where they are or what their circumstances are. It's like leveling the playing field. Yeah.

(5:36 - 6:07)
Giving everyone a chance to succeed. Exactly. And it's not just about test prep either. 

It's about unlocking opportunities. You know, when you can communicate confidently in English, you open doors to education, to career advancement, to travel, to connecting with people from all over the world. I'm getting chills just thinking about it. 

It's like we're witnessing a revolution in language learning and AI is right at the forefront. I think you're right. But, you know, we can't forget about that human element that the instructors in this study were so passionate about.

(6:08 - 6:46)
Oh, absolutely. I mean, can AI truly replace that experience of learning from a real person with all the nuances and complexities of human interaction? That's the million-dollar question, isn't it? Right. Does AI replace teachers? Does it make language learning less personal? Or can it actually enhance those connections and create even more opportunities for meaningful interaction? Those are some big questions. 

And this study is really just the tip of the iceberg. We've got a lot more to unpack here. You know, I think this is where a lot of people get a little uneasy about AI. 

Like, is it going to take over teaching and make everything feel impersonal? Right. Is it going to replace that human connection? Yeah. But honestly, I think that's missing the bigger picture.

(6:47 - 7:17)
So what is the bigger picture then? Well, I see AI more as a tool for empowerment. You know, instead of replacing teachers, it can actually free them up to focus on the things that they do best. OK. 

So like what kinds of things? Well, think about all the time teachers spend on things like grading or giving basic feedback. AI can take care of those more repetitive tasks. And that gives teachers more time and energy to connect with their students on a deeper level, you know, to provide guidance and really tailor their teaching to individual needs.

(7:18 - 7:27)
It's like AI is handling the logistics so teachers can focus on the human side of learning. Exactly. And when it comes to language learning, that human element is absolutely essential.

(7:27 - 7:38)
Because language is about so much more than just memorizing rules and vocabulary, right? Right. It's about communication, culture, connecting with others. And that's where that human touch is irreplaceable.

(7:38 - 7:56)
And that brings us back to the TOEFL speaking section, because that's where you really have to show that you can communicate effectively. Absolutely. It's not just about reciting memorized answers. 

It's about expressing yourself clearly and confidently in real world situations. Right. Like you might be asked to give a presentation or participate in a discussion.

(7:56 - 8:10)
Exactly. Things that you'll need to do in university, in your career and just in life in general. So how can AI help students develop those skills and overcome those anxieties? Because speaking tests can be pretty intimidating.

(8:10 - 8:25)
Well, that's where tools like Speech Rater can be incredibly helpful. So how does it work? Imagine you're practicing for the TOEFL speaking section and you have this platform that uses Speech Rater technology. You can record yourself answering practice questions just like you would on the actual test.

(8:25 - 8:47)
It's like a mock interview, but for your speaking. Exactly. And the best part is you get instant feedback. 

Speech Rater analyzes your pronunciation, your fluency, your grammar, vocabulary, even your coherence. So it tells you exactly what you need to work on. Right. 

It pinpoints your weaknesses and gives you specific suggestions on how to improve. That's amazing. It's like having a personal speech coach in your pocket.

(8:47 - 9:14)
And it's not just about identifying your weaknesses either. It's also about building confidence and developing those all-important communication skills. Right. 

Because the more you practice and the more feedback you get, the more comfortable you become with speaking. Exactly. And these AI-powered platforms can also give you targeted practice exercises, you know, helping you work on specific aspects of your speaking, whether it's pronunciation, vocabulary or just getting more comfortable with intonation and rhythm.

(9:14 - 9:22)
And this kind of personalized support is available to anyone with an internet connection. Right. It doesn't matter where you live or what your background is.

(9:22 - 9:34)
This is what's so exciting about AI in education, is breaking down those barriers and creating opportunities for everyone. And it's not just about individual learners either. It has the potential to transform entire education systems.

(9:35 - 9:47)
Well, AI can help educators personalize learning pathways, identify students who need extra support and create more engaging learning experiences for everyone. It's like we're moving towards a future where education is truly personalized. Right.

(9:48 - 9:56)
Where everyone has the chance to reach their full potential. I think so. And, you know, even with all these amazing benefits of AI, we can't forget about that research from Saudi Arabia.

(9:56 - 10:40)
Right. About how those instructors still value that personal connection. Exactly. 

AI is a powerful tool, but it's not a magic bullet. The best learning experiences are always going to involve a blend of technology and human interaction. So how do we find that balance? How do we make sure that AI is enhancing learning and not diminishing the importance of human connection? That's the key question. 

And it's something that we need to think carefully about as we move forward with AI in education. Yeah, it feels like we're at this really crucial point where AI is opening up all these incredible possibilities, but it's also making us ask some really tough questions about the future of learning. I agree. 

It's not a simple either situation. Right. Like it's not AI versus teachers.

(10:40 - 10:54)
Exactly. And if we look back at that study from Saudi Arabia, I think it gives us some clues. You know, even though those instructors saw the benefits of the lab tests, they still really wanted that direct connection with their students.

(10:54 - 11:05)
It's like they knew that something was missing, even with the efficiency and the standardized testing. Yeah. There's something about that human element that just can't be replicated by technology, no matter how advanced it gets.

(11:05 - 11:31)
So as we're moving forward with AI in education, we have to keep that in mind. Absolutely. It's not about choosing one over the other. 

It's about figuring out how to integrate technology and human interaction in a way that creates the best possible learning experience. So instead of thinking of AI as a replacement for teachers, we should be thinking of it as a tool that helps them do what they do best, right? Exactly. Things like inspiring, motivating, and guiding their students.

(11:31 - 11:44)
And that's especially important in language learning because connection and communication are so central. Think about it this way. AI can help you perfect your pronunciation, expand your vocabulary, and master grammar rules.

(11:44 - 11:59)
But it's a human teacher who can help you really understand the nuances of language. Like the cultural context or the emotional impact of what you're saying? Exactly. AI can give you the building blocks, but it takes a human teacher to help you build something truly meaningful with them.

(11:59 - 12:09)
I love that analogy, and I think it applies to education as a whole. Yeah, absolutely. We need to use AI in a way that strengthens human connection, not weakens it.

(12:09 - 12:21)
Couldn't agree more. So for all those TOEFL preppers out there, what does that actually look like in practice? Well, first of all, embrace the power of AI tools like the ones using speech reader technology. They can give you incredible feedback.

(12:21 - 12:33)
Exactly. They can help you identify those areas you need to work on so you can practice more effectively. So use those tools to really refine your pronunciation, your fluency, your grammar, but don't let that be the end of it.

(12:33 - 12:53)
Don't make AI your only teacher. Exactly. Find a language partner, join a conversation group, maybe work with a tutor. 

That back and forth real-time feedback and that sense of connection, it's invaluable. So it's like the best of both worlds. The precision and personalization of AI combined with the warmth and guidance of a human teacher.

(12:54 - 13:18)
That's the goal. And don't forget about the power of community either. Oh, yeah. 

Connecting with other learners. Right. Sharing your experiences, supporting each other. 

It can make a huge difference. It's amazing to think how much things are changing in the world of language learning and how AI is playing such a big role. It's exciting, but it's also a little daunting. 

It's definitely something we need to be talking about. And I think that's what makes these deep dives so important. I agree.

(13:18 - 13:30)
We're not just looking at the technical side of AI. We're also talking about the human side, the ethical implications. It's about using these tools in a responsible way to create a better learning experience for everyone.

(13:30 - 13:39)
Well said. And for all those TOEFL test takers out there, remember, embrace the technology, but don't forget the human connection. Keep learning and keep pushing yourself.

(13:39 - 13:46)
Best of luck on your language learning journey. This has been such a fascinating conversation. Thank you so much for sharing your expertise with us.

(13:46 - 13:55)
It's been my pleasure. And to everyone listening, we'd love to hear your thoughts on this. What are your hopes and concerns about AI in education? Leave us a comment or send us an email.

(13:55 - 14:15)
And for one final thought, as you continue your language learning journey, we've talked about how AI can personalize learning, but can it ever truly replicate that joy of a spontaneous conversation? That's spark of connection that happens when we share ideas and stories with other human beings. Something to think about until next time. Happy learning.