Synchronous vs. Asynchronous Assessments: Finding the Best Approach for Evaluating Communication Skills

In this episode of the TOEFL Speaking Prep Podcast, we dive into the dynamic world of oral language assessments, exploring the key differences between synchronous and asynchronous evaluations. From the early days of tape-recorded interviews to AI-powered speech analysis tools like SpeechRater, we trace the evolution of assessing communication skills. Learn how real-time video interactions and personalized feedback are transforming TOEFL preparation, ensuring students develop fluency, coherence, and confidence in their speaking abilities. Whether you're prepping for TOEFL or intrigued by the future of education, this discussion unpacks how technology bridges access gaps and personalizes learning experiences.

Tune in to uncover which assessment approach—synchronous or asynchronous—might be the best fit for your communication goals! 🎙️

Source

Free TOEFL Speaking practice:

• My Speaking Score

Free resources:

• TOEFL Speaking Course
• SpeechRater Blog
• SpeechRater Knowledge Base

Social:

• Follow us on Facebook
• Subscribe on YouTube

My Speaking Score serves 000s of users across the globe by helping them data-power their TOEFL Speaking prep.

Transcript

Okay, so we're going to be doing a deep dive today on using technology for something that I think a lot of people are probably familiar with, oral language assessments. Yeah, especially the TOEFL Speaking Test.

(0:31 - 0:40)
Right, exactly. So we've got a bunch of research here. And I think what we should probably start off by doing is just give you a quick overview of what we're going to be talking about.

(0:40 - 0:59)
Sure. Okay, so basically we want to look at how technology can be used to assess speaking ability, especially for people who are learning English as a second language. And we want to see how well these different technologies actually measure up to what it means to communicate effectively in the real world.

(0:59 - 1:09)
Yeah, like does it actually capture what it means to have a conversation? Right. Not just like grammar and vocabulary, but like actually being able to understand someone and respond appropriately. Exactly.

(1:10 - 1:21)
And we also want to think about how all of this connects to students around the world who are prepping for the TOEFL. Yeah, because like the TOEFL is a high stakes test for a lot of people. It can determine if they get into a university or get a job.

(1:22 - 1:36)
So the stakes are high. And there are a lot of challenges, especially for students who might not have access to expensive test prep resources. So yeah, we're going to be looking at everything from like old school tape recordings to the latest AI powered tools.

(1:36 - 1:41)
To basically like the whole history of technology in language assessment. Exactly. Yeah.

(1:41 - 1:45)
And we'll see how things have evolved and where the field might be headed in the future. Sounds good. Cool.

(1:47 - 1:57)
So I remember back in the day when I was studying languages, I actually used to practice with cassette tapes. Could you believe that? Oh yeah, those are the days. Talk about a blast from the past.

(1:58 - 2:11)
But seriously, like those tape mediated interviews were one of the first ways to try to standardize oral assessments. Yeah, the idea was to eliminate the human factor. So everyone would hear the same questions and there wouldn't be any bias in the scoring.

(2:11 - 2:17)
Right. But let's be real. Talking to a tape recorder isn't exactly the most engaging conversation partner.

(2:17 - 2:30)
Oh, not really. It's like trying to have a deep discussion with a brick wall. There's no back and forth, no chance to clarify anything, and definitely no room for those all important communication skills that are crucial for the TOEFL.

(2:30 - 2:37)
You're telling me. Okay. So then came the rise of computers and we started to see the emergence of automated assessments.

(2:38 - 2:41)
Yeah. Like systems like PhonePass, which is now known as Versant. Right.

(2:41 - 2:58)
So these systems use computers to deliver prompts and assess things like pronunciation and fluency. And they were definitely a step forward in terms of consistency and efficiency, but they still primarily focused on like structured tasks like repeating sentences or reading aloud. Yeah.

(2:58 - 3:08)
So they were good for testing basic language skills, but they didn't necessarily capture a student's ability to hold natural conversation. Or navigate the complexities of real world communication. Right.

(3:08 - 3:12)
Exactly. Which is a big part of what the TOEFL speaking test is all about. For sure.

(3:12 - 3:21)
Okay. So where did things go from there? Well, the next evolution was asynchronous assessments like the TOEFL IBT speaking and TOEIC speaking tests. Oh, yeah.

(3:21 - 3:26)
I've heard of those. So these tests use pre-recorded prompts delivered via computer. Okay.

(3:26 - 3:36)
So what's the advantage of that? Well, it allows students to respond at their own pace and it gives them more time to think through their answers. That makes sense. I guess it's less stressful than having to respond on the spot.

(3:36 - 3:41)
Right. But it still doesn't quite replicate the pressure and spontaneity of a real TOEFL interview. Yeah.

(3:41 - 3:54)
True. So asynchronous assessments are great for practicing specific types of questions. But they don't fully capture the interactive nature of communication that the TOEFL speaking test aims to assess.

(3:54 - 4:02)
Okay. So we've gone from tapes to computers. But it seems like we're still not quite there yet in terms of replicating the real TOEFL experience.

(4:03 - 4:20)
Where do we go from here? Well, this is where things start to get really interesting. We're now seeing the emergence of synchronous assessments that use video conferencing or even virtual environments to allow for real-time interaction between students and examiners. So it's like taking a TOEFL speaking test on Zoom.

(4:20 - 4:23)
You got it. That sounds way more realistic. Right.

(4:23 - 4:36)
These technologies are bringing us closer to replicating authentic communication, which is crucial for assessing those real-world speaking skills that are essential for success on the TOEFL. Okay. I'm starting to see how this could be really helpful for students.

(4:36 - 4:46)
So they can actually demonstrate their ability to communicate effectively in a variety of scenarios. Exactly. And examiners can get a more holistic view of their communication skills.

(4:46 - 5:00)
That's intriguing. But I wonder how much these synchronous assessments really replicate the stress of a real TOEFL interview. I mean, talking to a computer screen is still not the same as being in a room with an examiner, right? You bring up a valid point.

(5:00 - 5:12)
While these technologies provide a richer and more authentic assessment experience, they do have limitations. And there are also logistical challenges with implementing these kinds of assessments on a large scale. Yeah.

(5:12 - 5:21)
Like, how do you ensure the security and integrity of live video feeds or a virtual environment? Exactly. There are definitely some hurdles to overcome. Okay.

(5:21 - 5:39)
So we've come a long way from those cassette tapes to the world of video conferencing, but it seems like there's still room for improvement when it comes to replicating the real TOEFL experience. Yeah. What's the next frontier? Well, this is where AI starts to play a truly transformative role, particularly with platforms that leverage speech rater technology.

(5:39 - 5:44)
Ooh, speech rater. I've heard that name thrown around a lot lately. It's pretty cutting edge stuff.

(5:45 - 6:00)
Imagine having access to a virtual TOEFL coach that can analyze your speech in incredible detail, providing personalized feedback on everything from pronunciation and fluency to grammar, vocabulary, and even how well you organize your thoughts. Hold on. That sounds amazing.

(6:00 - 6:15)
Yeah. Are we talking about those AI-powered conversation partners we hear so much about? The ones that can actually understand you and respond in a meaningful way? You got it. These spoken dialogue systems, or SDSs, are still under development, but they hold enormous potential for language learning and assessment.

(6:16 - 6:26)
And when it comes to TOEFL speaking, test preparation platforms leveraging speech rater technology are already making a significant impact. Okay. This is all starting to sound really exciting.

(6:26 - 6:35)
But before we get too carried away, let's take a step back and really break down what speech rater is and how it actually works. Sounds like a plan. Okay.

(6:35 - 6:41)
So let's dive into this speech rater thing. What exactly is it and how does it actually work? Yeah. Break it down for me.

(6:41 - 6:48)
Okay. So imagine it this way. When you speak this face, you're not just conveying words.

(6:48 - 6:55)
You're using pronunciation, intonation, pauses, even like the way you structure your sentences to get your message across. Right. Right.

(6:55 - 6:59)
Like it's more than just the words themselves. Exactly. And speech rater captures all of that.

(7:00 - 7:09)
So it's not just about grammar and vocabulary. Nope. The TOEFL speaking test evaluates your ability to communicate effectively, and that involves much more than just grammatical accuracy.

(7:10 - 7:17)
Speech rater takes all of those subtle nuances into account. Okay. I'm starting to see how this could be incredibly helpful for students.

(7:17 - 7:30)
But walk me through the process. What happens when a student uses a platform with speech rater technology? Okay. So typically the student would be presented with a TOEFL style speaking prompt, just like they would encounter on the actual exam.

(7:30 - 7:46)
And then they record their response using the platform's recording feature. And then what? The AI takes over? Yep. Speech rater analyzes the recording on multiple levels, providing feedback on pronunciation, fluency, vocabulary, grammar, even things like discourse coherence.

(7:46 - 7:49)
Hold on. Discourse coherence. That's a new one.

(7:49 - 8:08)
What exactly does that mean? So basically it's about how well your ideas flow together. The TOEFL examiners are listening for how well you connect your ideas and present a clear, organized response. And speech rater can actually analyze your speech and tell you if your response sounds choppy, if you're using effective transitions, if your ideas are logically connected.

(8:09 - 8:14)
Wow. That's pretty impressive. It's like having an examiner's ear analyzing your every word and phrase.

(8:14 - 8:24)
But it's one thing to get feedback and another to actually use it to improve. How do these platforms help students make tangible progress? Right. So that's where the personalized practice comes in.

(8:24 - 8:36)
Remember, the goal isn't just to identify your weaknesses, it's to actually improve them. So it's not enough to just tell me I need to work on my pronunciation, or that my sentences are a bit disjointed. I need to know how actually fix those issues.

(8:36 - 8:45)
Exactly. And these platforms do just that. They often provide targeted exercises, tips, even sample responses to help you strengthen those specific areas.

(8:45 - 9:04)
Okay, so let's say speech rater tells me I need to work on my pronunciation of certain vowel sounds. Would the platform then give me exercises to practice those sounds? Exactly. It might offer pronunciation drills, visual aids showing correct tongue placement, or even comparisons of your pronunciation to that of a native speaker.

(9:04 - 9:12)
This is starting to sound less like an assessment tool and more like a personal language coach. That's a great way to put it. And it goes beyond just pronunciation.

(9:13 - 9:27)
If speech rater detects that you're using simple vocabulary, it might suggest more sophisticated synonyms or phrases to enhance your language. So if I keep saying good, when I could be using words like excellent or fantastic, speech rater would call me out on that. Yep.

(9:27 - 9:36)
It would push you to expand your vocabulary and use more nuanced language, which is something the TOEFL examiners look for. Okay, this is all very cool. But I have a question.

(9:37 - 9:49)
How does speech rater handle different accents? I mean, English is spoken all over the world, and there's so much variation in pronunciation. That's a great question. And it's something that researchers are constantly working to improve.

(9:50 - 10:04)
Speech raters train on a diverse data set of accents, allowing it to recognize and understand a wide range of pronunciations. So it's not penalizing students for having an accent, as long as their speech is clear and understandable. That's right.

(10:04 - 10:15)
The goal is to help students communicate effectively, not to erase their individuality or cultural background. Makes sense. Okay, so we've talked about the personalized feedback and targeted practice aspects.

(10:15 - 10:32)
But how do these platforms track student progress? Can they tell if I'm actually improving over time? Absolutely. One of the key advantages of these AI-powered platforms is their ability to track your progress over time. They keep a record of your scores, your strengths and weaknesses, and how you're responding to the feedback and exercises.

(10:32 - 10:46)
So it's like having a detailed report card that shows me exactly where I started, how far I've come, and where I still need to focus my efforts. Exactly. And some platforms even use this data to predict your likely score on the actual TOEFL speaking test.

(10:46 - 10:51)
That's amazing. But let's zoom out a bit. We've talked a lot about the technical aspects of SpeechRater.

(10:52 - 11:13)
How is AI impacting education and test prep beyond just the TOEFL? Well, what we're seeing with AI-powered language learning is just the tip of the iceberg. Imagine a world where students all over the globe have access to personalized learning experiences tailored to their specific needs and goals. AI can adapt to your pace, your learning style, even your interests.

(11:14 - 11:23)
So instead of a one-size-fits-all approach, it's like having a custom-made education right. It is. Think about students in remote areas who might not have access to qualified teachers.

(11:23 - 11:31)
AI can bring expert instruction right to their fingertips. That's a game-changer. It's bridging the gap between those who have access to quality education and those who don't.

(11:31 - 11:44)
And it's not just about access to information, it's about personalized support. Imagine having an AI tutor that can answer your questions, clarify concepts, provide encouragement whenever you need it. It's like having a 247 study buddy who never gets tired or frustrated.

(11:45 - 11:54)
Exactly. AI has the potential to empower learners of all ages and backgrounds, helping them achieve their educational goals and reach their full potential. This is all very exciting.

(11:54 - 12:12)
But as with any new technology, there are always concerns. What are some of the potential downsides or challenges we need to be aware of when it comes to AI in education? That's an important question. One concern is that AI could be used to replace teachers altogether, which is something I don't think anyone wants to see happen.

(12:12 - 12:20)
Right. I mean, teachers bring so much more to the table than just delivering content and assessing knowledge. They inspire, they mentor, they create a supportive learning environment.

(12:21 - 12:30)
Those are things AI can't replicate, at least not yet. Exactly. The most effective approach is likely to involve a blend of human and AI interaction, leveraging the strengths of both race.

(12:31 - 12:55)
Teachers can use AI tools to enhance their teaching, personalize instruction, and provide more targeted feedback while still maintaining that crucial human connection with their students. So it's not about replacing teachers, but about empowering them with new tools and resources to help their students succeed. And another challenge is ensuring that AI systems are developed and implemented in a way that's fair and equitable for all students.

(12:55 - 13:14)
We need to be mindful of potential biases in the data used to train these algorithms and make sure that AI is being used to bridge opportunity gaps, not widen them. That's a crucial point. AI has the potential to revolutionize education, but it's up to us to ensure that it's used responsibly and ethically to benefit all learners.

(13:14 - 13:20)
Couldn't agree more. Now let's bring our focus back to the TOEFL and those platforms utilizing SpeechRater. There's so much more to uncover.

(13:21 - 13:34)
All right. So we've talked about personalized feedback and all the amazing things that AI can do to analyze speech, but how does this actually help someone who's prepping for the TOEFL speaking test? Okay. So let's say you're working on a practice TOEFL speaking prompt, maybe something about your favorite book.

(13:34 - 13:46)
You record your response using a platform that has SpeechRater built in. Okay. And then what? Well, SpeechRater analyzes your response and gives you feedback like, your pronunciation was clear and your ideas were well organized.

(13:47 - 14:03)
But you could enhance your vocabulary by replacing good book with captivating novel or thought-provoking memoir. Oh, so it's not just pointing out errors, it's actually suggesting specific ways to improve and it's giving me language that I can use to impress those TOEFL examiners. Exactly.

(14:03 - 14:17)
It's about taking your response to the next level. And it might even point out things that you weren't even aware of, like you tend to speak a bit too fast when you're nervous. Try pausing briefly after each key point to emphasize it and give yourself a moment to think.

(14:17 - 14:32)
Whoa, that's like having a human tutor right there with you. Yeah. But can it help with more than just pronunciation? Like, what if I need help with structuring my response or organizing my ideas? Well, some of these platforms actually provide sample responses from high-scoring TOEFL test takers.

(14:32 - 14:42)
So you can compare your response to the sample and see how a more effective response is structured. Oh, that's interesting. So it's like having a model to follow, a blueprint for success.

(14:42 - 14:55)
Exactly. And because the feedback is so specific, you can really focus your practice on the areas where you need the most help. So instead of spending hours doing generic speaking exercises, you're working on the things that will actually make a difference on test day.

(14:55 - 15:07)
This is making a lot of sense to me now. But you know, this goes way beyond just the TOEFL, right? This whole idea of AI-powered language learning has implications for education in general. Oh, absolutely.

(15:07 - 15:21)
What we're seeing with these platforms is just a glimpse of what's possible. Imagine a world where every student has access to personalized learning experiences that are tailored to their specific needs and goals. Yeah, it's like having a custom-made education.

(15:21 - 15:30)
Exactly. AI can adapt to your pace, your learning style, even your interests. And think about students in remote areas who might not have access to qualified teachers.

(15:31 - 15:36)
AI can bring expert instruction right to their fingertips. It's amazing. It's like democratizing education.

(15:36 - 15:42)
Making it accessible to everyone. And it's not just about access to information. It's about personalized support.

(15:43 - 15:54)
Imagine having an AI tutor that can answer your questions, clarify concepts, provide encouragement whenever you need it. That would be incredible. Like having a study buddy who's always available and never gets tired.

(15:54 - 16:01)
Exactly. AI has the potential to truly empower learners of all ages and backgrounds. We've covered a lot of ground today.

(16:01 - 16:14)
It's been quite a journey from those old cassette tapes to the mind-blowing world of AI-powered language learning. It really has. And it's clear that AI is already having a huge impact on how we learn and prepare for challenges like the TOEFL speaking test.

(16:15 - 16:24)
And as AI continues to evolve, we can only imagine what the future holds for language learning and education as a whole. It's an exciting time to be a learner. That's for sure.

(16:24 - 16:36)
Absolutely. So to everyone out there who's on their own language learning journey, remember that AI can be a powerful ally. Explore those AI-powered platforms, embrace the personalized feedback, and keep pushing yourself to improve.

(16:37 - 16:47)
You might just surprise yourself with what you can achieve. And who knows? Maybe one day we'll be having this conversation with an AI host and an AI expert. Until then, keep learning and keep exploring.