AI vs. Human Educators: Comparing Learning Outcomes in Teaching Videos

In this episode of The TOEFL Speaking Prep Podcast for the AI Era, we explore groundbreaking research comparing AI and human educators in creating educational content. We dive into a study that pits AI-generated teaching videos against human-made ones, analyzing how effectively each method helps learners absorb material and prepare for challenges like the TOEFL.

Discover the potential of AI as a teaching assistant, from grading and tailoring lesson plans to providing personalized feedback. We discuss how AI tools, like SpeechRater, can offer real-time guidance on pronunciation, fluency, and vocabulary, empowering students to excel in the TOEFL speaking section. But it’s not just about technology replacing educators—it’s about creating a blended learning model where AI and human teachers collaborate to enhance education.

Join us as we unpack how this innovative approach can make learning more accessible, engaging, and effective for everyone, bridging global gaps in education and opening doors to new opportunities. Tune in to explore how AI might be the key to overcoming language barriers and achieving your academic dreams!

Key topics:

• AI vs. human educators: strengths and challenges.
• How AI tools enhance TOEFL preparation.
• The role of blended learning in modern education.
• Real-world implications of AI-powered personalized learning.

Don’t miss this deep dive into the future of learning!

Source

Free TOEFL Speaking practice:

• My Speaking Score

Free resources:

• TOEFL Speaking Course
• SpeechRater Blog
• SpeechRater Knowledge Base

Social:

• Follow us on Facebook
• Subscribe on YouTube

My Speaking Score serves 000s of users across the globe by helping them data-power their TOEFL Speaking prep.

Transcript

All right, so today we're diving into some research. And this one, I think, has some pretty big implications for anyone out there who's studying for a big test, especially if you're thinking about something like the TOEFL. 

You know how stressful it can be to prep for that speaking section, right? What if AI could actually help you out? That's kind of what this research is looking at. They basically pitted AI against human teachers in a video making showdown. Yeah, and it's really interesting because they didn't just have the AI, you know, generate some random educational content. 

They actually went pretty deep and created videos on very specific operations management techniques. So things like 5S, which focuses on workplace organization, and then Tree's Ground, which is like a structured problem-solving method. And they had one set of videos that were made by, you know, professors, the old-fashioned way, and then a whole other set that was entirely AI produced using tools like ChatGPT for the script and then Movio for the actual video itself. 

So wait, they had AI avatars actually, like, teaching these concepts. That's wild. But how did they test that the AI was actually any good at teaching? So they recruited people online and had them watch either the human or the AI-made videos, and then they gave everyone a quiz to see how well they actually absorbed the material.

(1:55 - 3:54)
And, you know, thinking about the TOEFL for a second, that speaking portion can be so intimidating for a lot of people. But imagine if you had an AI system that could help you practice and give them feedback, you know, just like these videos were tested on. That's where I think this research gets really, really relevant. 

Okay, so they had the videos, they had the test subjects, and they had the quizzes. What were the results? Did people even like watching the AI videos? Yeah, that was the first thing that jumped out at me. The viewers actually rated the human-made videos as slightly more enjoyable to watch. 

Ah, so there's still something about that human touch that AI hasn't quite replicated, huh? It seems that way. You know, it could be those subtle things like tone of voice, natural pauses, or even, you know, a well-placed joke that make human teachers engaging. AI is getting incredibly good at mimicking human speech, but, you know, there's still a little bit of a gap when it comes to creating a truly natural and relatable teaching style. 

But did people learn any better from the human-made videos, or was this just about, like, entertainment value? Well, this is where it gets really interesting. There was no significant difference in how well people scored on the quiz, regardless of whether they watched the human or the AI taught video. Whoa, okay, so you're telling me that AI might be just as good at teaching certain concepts as a real human? That's exactly what this research suggests. 

Now, of course, it's just one study, and we need more research to see, you know, how this plays out in different subjects and learning environments. But for something like the TOEFL, where you really need to master specific language skills, I think the potential here is huge. So how does this actually connect to the TOEFL? It's one thing to learn about, you know, workplace organization from a video, but the TOEFL is a whole different beast. 

Right. Well, imagine a platform that uses AI to analyze your speaking. You know, just like those quizzes measured learning in this study, there's this technology called SpeechRater that can give you incredibly detailed feedback on things like your pronunciation fluency and vocabulary, all things that are really crucial for a good TOEFL speaking score.

(3:54 - 4:23)
That sounds like a dream come true for anyone who's struggling with the speaking section, no more awkward silences or, you know, fumbling for words. Exactly. And the best part is this type of AI-powered feedback isn't limited by location or resources. 

Imagine students all over the world, no matter where they live or what their background is. Having access to this level of personalized support as they prep for the TOEFL, it could truly level the playing field. And it all stems from research like this, you know, showing us that AI can actually be an incredibly effective teacher.

(4:23 - 4:47)
This is pretty mind-blowing, but we've only scratched the surface of this research, right? Oh, absolutely. There's so much more to unpack here. For starters, the study focused on operations management, but what about other subjects? Could AI help us learn languages more effectively or tackle, you know, complex topics in history or science? The possibilities are kind of endless, and I'm really excited to see where this research leads.

(4:47 - 5:21)
I'm with you. So for everyone listening who's feeling that pre-TOEFL stress don't give up hope just yet, AI might be coming to your rescue soon. But we'll dive into those details in a bit. 

First, I want to go back to the study itself. We talked about people liking the human-made videos a little better, but I'm curious about the AI video content itself. Yeah, yeah. 

So the AI-generated videos, they were actually surprisingly good, especially considering, you know, this is still relatively new technology. The avatars were realistic, and the information was presented pretty clearly and concisely. And remember, they were using ChatGPT to actually write the script, so the content itself was, you know, high quality.

(5:21 - 5:38)
That makes sense. ChatGPT is pretty amazing at generating text that sounds like a human wrote it. But I'm guessing it wasn't perfect. 

There must have been some, like, quirks or limitations with the AI-generated videos, right? Oh, yeah. Definitely. There were definitely areas where the AI could improve.

(5:38 - 5:57)
Like, for example, the pacing of the video sometimes felt a little bit off, and the delivery lacked some of the nuances and expressiveness that you would see in a human teacher. But, you know, you got to remember, this was specifically for operations management. When it comes to language learning, those subtle aspects of human communication become even more important.

(5:57 - 6:11)
Mastering a language isn't just about memorizing vocabulary and grammar rules. It's about understanding cultural context and picking up on those subtle cues, and expressing yourself in a natural and engaging way. That's what makes the TOEFL speaking section so challenging.

(6:11 - 6:21)
It's designed to assess your ability to communicate effectively in real-world situations. Exactly. And that's where I think AI-powered tools have the potential to be truly transformative.

(6:22 - 6:39)
Imagine a platform that not only analyzes your pronunciation and fluency, but also gives you feedback on your tone, your intonation, even your use of idioms and colloquial expressions. Okay, now that is next level. It'd be like having a personal language coach in your pocket, helping you refine every aspect of your speaking skills.

(6:40 - 6:48)
Yeah, that's the goal. And it's becoming more and more achievable every day. We're already seeing platforms that are leveraging speech reader technology to provide this level of detailed feedback.

(6:49 - 7:12)
You know, helping students pinpoint their weaknesses and practice more effectively. For someone prepping for the TOEFL, especially that speaking section, you know, that kind of personalized guidance could be invaluable. Absolutely. 

It could be a game changer for students who don't have access to traditional tutors or language classes. But let's go back to those AI-generated teaching videos for a moment. The study focused on very specific topics in operations management.

(7:13 - 7:31)
Do you think AI could be just as effective at teaching something like English grammar or pronunciation? Hmm, that's a great question. And it's one that researchers are definitely actively exploring. Language learning presents some unique challenges because it involves so many different skills, you know, listening, speaking, reading, writing, and of course, that cultural understanding.

(7:31 - 7:46)
But I think the potential is definitely there. You know, we're already seeing AI being used to develop personalized language learning apps, create interactive exercises, and even simulate conversations with native speakers. So it's not just about replacing human teachers with AI bots.

(7:46 - 8:00)
It's about using AI to actually enhance the learning experience and make it more accessible and effective for everyone. And this brings us back to the TOEFL. You mentioned earlier that AI could help level the playing field for students around the world.

(8:01 - 8:12)
Can you kind of elaborate on that a bit? Sure. So the TOEFL is, you know, a gateway to higher education and professional opportunities for millions of people worldwide. But access to quality test prep resources isn't always equal.

(8:12 - 8:27)
You know, students in some countries might have access to expensive test prep courses and private tutors, while students in other countries might be limited to, you know, outdated textbooks and online forums. Yeah, that creates a huge disadvantage for those students. It absolutely does.

(8:27 - 8:48)
And that's where I think AI can really make a difference. Imagine an AI-powered platform that provides personalized TOEFL prep regardless of a student's location or their financial resources. You know, this platform could offer adaptive learning modules, targeted practice exercises, and even mock speaking tests with detailed feedback generated by speech radar technology.

(8:48 - 9:02)
It sounds like a dream come true for anyone who's ever felt overwhelmed or discouraged by the TOEFL prep process. Yeah, it's about empowering learners and giving them the tools they need to succeed regardless of their background or their circumstances. And that's a vision that I'm really excited about.

(9:02 - 9:21)
I'm with you on that. This research, while focused on operations management, it really does point to a future where learning and test prep are more personalized, accessible, and effective for everyone. But it's not just about the technology itself, is it? It's about how we use it to create a more equitable and inclusive educational landscape.

(9:22 - 9:37)
You're absolutely right. You know, AI is a powerful tool, but it's up to us to use it responsibly and ethically to ensure that it benefits all learners and helps us create a world where everyone has the opportunity to reach their full potential. And that's something worth striving for.

(9:37 - 9:40)
I completely agree. This has been an incredibly enlightening conversation. Yeah.

(9:40 - 9:50)
And it's definitely given us a lot to think about. But before we wrap up, I want to touch on one more aspect of the study. So one thing that really struck me was that the researchers, they didn't see this as like a battle of AI versus human teachers.

(9:51 - 9:59)
They actually proposed this blended learning model where both kind of work together. Yeah, and that's a really crucial point, I think. You know, it's not about replacing teachers.

(9:59 - 10:19)
It's about giving them new tools and strategies. So imagine AI handling things like grading or, you know, tailoring basic lesson plans, which would then free up human teachers to focus on all the things that AI can't do. Things like mentoring, providing emotional support, you know, fostering a deeper love of learning.

(10:19 - 10:29)
Right. So AI becomes like this superpower teaching assistant handling more routine tasks while the human teacher can really connect with each student on a personal level. Precisely.

(10:29 - 10:44)
And, you know, it goes beyond just time saving, too. Think about how AI could analyze student data to pinpoint exactly where someone is struggling and then suggest personalized learning paths or activities that the teacher could then implement. It's like having customized tutoring built into the classroom.

(10:44 - 10:58)
That's incredible. It would be especially helpful for students prepping for a test like the TOEFL, where they need to focus on very specific skills. You could have AI identifying, you know, the areas where a student's pronunciation or grammar needs the most work.

(10:58 - 11:12)
And then the human teacher could provide that really targeted guidance and feedback. Exactly. It's about combining the strengths of both AI and human educators to create a truly personalized and effective learning experience.

(11:12 - 11:20)
And this isn't just, you know, futuristic speculation either. We're already seeing this blended model starting to emerge in classrooms around the world. That's really encouraging.

(11:20 - 11:36)
It sounds like AI really has the potential to make education more accessible, engaging and effective for everyone, whether you're studying for a big test like the TOEFL or just, you know, trying to learn a new language. I couldn't agree more. And, you know, it's not just about improving test scores or, you know, academic performance.

(11:37 - 11:55)
It's about empowering individuals, helping them overcome language barriers and opening doors to new opportunities. You know, imagine a world where anyone, regardless of their location or background, can access high quality educational resources and achieve their full potential. That's a vision worth striving for.

(11:55 - 12:13)
And it all starts with research like this, pushing the boundaries of what's possible and showing us just how transformative AI can be in the realm of education. So for everyone listening who's feeling intimidated by the TOEFL or any other challenging learning goal, remember that AI might be the key to unlocking your potential and achieving your dreams. Absolutely.

(12:14 - 12:24)
Don't be afraid to explore, you know, the AI powered learning tools that are already out there. And stay curious about all the incredible advancements that are happening in this field. The future of education is brighter than ever.

(12:24 - 12:31)
And we're all on this exciting journey together. Well said. That's a wrap on our deep dive into AI and the future of learning.

(12:31 - 12:58)
We've covered a lot of ground today, from AI avatars to personalized language learning and the potential of a blended learning model. You know, we've really seen how AI can empower both learners and educators, opening doors to a more personalized, accessible and engaging world of learning. And most importantly, we've seen how this research connects to the real world challenges students face when prepping for the TOEFL and how AI could be the game changer that helps them succeed.

(12:58 - 13:14)
Yeah, and we'd love to hear your thoughts on this exciting topic. What excites you most about the potential of AI in education? Share your ideas and experiences with us on social media using the hashtag, hashtag the deep dive. And until next time, keep those brains buzzing and those learning adventures going strong.

(13:14 - 13:20)
We'll see you back here soon for another fascinating deep dive into the world of knowledge and discovery. Bye for now.